Casey Spencer

Attorney Profile

Courtroom experience that strengthens every case.

Casey Spencer is a former Monroe County Assistant District Attorney who has handled hundreds of cases and spent years working in courtrooms across the region.

That experience matters whether you are facing criminal charges or seeking compensation after an injury. Casey knows how to evaluate evidence, question witnesses, anticipate the other side's arguments, and prepare a case for court.

Attorney Casey Spencer
Casey Spencer Attorney and former Assistant District Attorney

Trial Experience

Prepared for the courtroom from the start.

Casey served in the Major Felonies Bureau and handled arraignments, hearings, motions, bench trials, and jury trials. Her cases ranged from traffic offenses to the most serious felony charges.

  • Former prosecutor in the Major Felonies Bureau
  • Handled hundreds of criminal cases
  • Conducted hearings, motions, bench trials, and jury trials
  • Practiced in town, city, county, and New York State Supreme Courts

That work taught her how strong cases are built—and how they are challenged. She brings that same preparation and attention to every client she represents.

Why courtroom experience matters in a personal injury case.

Most personal injury cases are resolved without a trial. But the strength of a claim often depends on whether it has been prepared to stand up in court.

Casey's courtroom experience helps her evaluate witnesses, organize evidence, identify weaknesses before the other side can use them, and present a client's story clearly and persuasively.

She also previously defended personal injury claims for insurance companies. That experience gives her insight into how insurers evaluate claims, where they may push back, and what can strengthen a case before negotiations begin.

What that means for you.

Whether your case involves criminal charges or a serious injury, the other side will closely examine the facts. Casey approaches each matter by asking what can be proven, what may be challenged, and what needs to be done now to protect the client.

You get practical advice, careful preparation, and an attorney who is comfortable advocating for you in the courtroom when necessary.

Education and advocacy.

Casey was born and raised in the Southern Tier. She attended the University at Buffalo for undergraduate school and continued at the University at Buffalo School of Law, where she received her Juris Doctor.

While in law school, she competed in regional moot court competitions and won awards for her advocacy skills.

Rochester area roots.

Casey lives in the Rochester area with her husband and children. The firm represents clients in Rochester, Monroe County, the surrounding region, and in select matters across New York State.

585-888-1180 Free Case Review